Directions: One statement is given followed by two arguments, I and II. You have to consider the statement to be true, even if it seems to be at variance from commonly known facts. The arguments might be FOR or AGAINST the statement. An argument might be called “strong” if it stands on its intended purpose FOR or AGAINST the given statement. You have to decide which argument is strong in relation to the above statement.
Statement: There should be an immediate permanent ban on the cutting of trees.
Arguments:
- Yes. This move would greatly restore the balance in the ecosystem.
- No. The industries based on timber would be severely damaged after this drastic step.
1
Only argument I is strong
2
Only argument II is strong
3
Either I or II is strong
4
Neither I nor II is strong
5
Both I and II are strong